
Grade: 1 1/2 stars (maybe 2 stars...it was that bad, I just didn't enjoy it)
Retelling of Robin Hood, but with Will Scarlet as a girl dressed up as a boy. The central love triangle annoyed me quite a bit, unfortunately. Also (this is totally unfair on the book and definitely my fault), I happen to be a big fan of Little John in all retellings. He was quite interesting in this one, so if there's a sequel about him I might read it, but he was also really annoying. Robin was rather boring (maybe I just missed something there because I was too caught up in how annoyed I was at the love triangle?), and Much wasn't in it nearly enough.

Grade: 1 star
Creeeepy. In a bad way. At least for me. This is about two girls whose father was a serial killer, and they sort of take after him. There are a bunch of stories about serial killers (or those tempted to that sort of thing) that I like (like say Dexter or I Hunt Killers), but this one was just weird and unpleasant. There was a strange fantasy element incorporated as well that just made it all weirder.

Grade: 2 1/2 stars
Good story about a lonely girl whose parents are famous actors with a secret. A bit young for me, but the illustrations were awesome. Like the above, there was a fair amount of creepiness, but I liked this creepiness quite a bit.

Grade: 3 1/2 stars

"Lab Rat One" by Andrea K. Höst
Grade: 3 1/2 stars
Follow up to Stray. Basically see my thoughts for the first one. This one is slightly less exciting because everything is less new, but there starts to be some interesting plot developments (as opposed to simply exploring and discovering a new civilization).

Grade: 3 stars
Follow up to Stray and Lab Rat One. Good final section, although perhaps my least favourite of the three. It can be very difficult to properly write about someone who is settling down after having found their mate and home and all that. I'm not sure if Höst quite succeeds, at least for me. It was still interesting--I did like her children and her partner and the plot developments. It just wasn't quite as interesting as the previous two.
4 comments:
I've been torn about reading Scarlet; the reviews I've read seem mixed. Since I am a fan of Robin Hood retellings, I'll probably get around to it eventually, but I feel no hurry. I also just realized it's supposed to be the start of a series. That could be very interesting.
I think you should try it out, at least. It's pretty light reading and shouldn't take too long. Obviously I didn't like it much, but other reviewers have, as you mentioned.
Speaking of Robin Hood retellings, have you read Robin McKinley's "Outlaws of Sherwood"?
I have read Robin McKinley's Outlaws of Sherwood--a long time ago. I remember being flabbergasted that Robin couldn't shoot an arrow. ;)
Haha, yes. I quite liked that one, even Robin with his horrible shooting. It was definitely an interesting take on him. :)
Post a Comment